Sell Your Cards / Consignment
Turn your collection into cash — or something bigger
At Betz Legacy, we make selling or consigning your cards simple, transparent, and secure — whether it's a single high-value card or a collection built over decades.
We buy
We're always buying sports cards and collections. As a local shop inside Crossgates Mall, we make the process simple, fair, and straightforward.
Selling your cards
A handful of singles or a full collection — here's how it works.
Small lots (under 10–15 cards)Stop by anytime, no appointment needed.
Larger collectionsSend photos or a list ahead of time so we can prepare a faster, more accurate offer.
EvaluationEvery card is evaluated using current market & trending data, condition, and demand.
Your offerYou'll receive an offer on the spot in most cases. No pressure — accept, decline, or take time to think it over.
Cash or store credit
We offer two ways to sell.
Cash
30–70%
of established market value — quick, immediate payment.
Store credit
50–85%
of established market value — usable on anything in the store.
We're most interested in high-end singles, star players, graded cards, sealed hobby product, and desirable vintage or modern cards in strong condition. We're more selective with bulk commons and lower-value cards, but we're happy to take a look and give you an honest answer either way.
Consignment services
At Betz Legacy, consignment is the best option if you have premium cards and want the highest possible return without doing any of the work yourself. We professionally photograph your cards, write detailed descriptions, list them across multiple platforms, and actively market them to serious buyers while handling all customer service, payment processing, shipping supplies, packaging, insurance, and shipping costs. We also manage any buyer issues or returns, so you simply drop your cards off at our Crossgates Mall location and we take care of everything from start to finish.
Consignment payout rates
Choose store credit instead of cash and we'll add an extra 5% to your payout, at every tier. No listing fees, no hidden costs.
What we accept for consignment
How consignment works
Bring your cards inOr send photos and a list ahead of time for larger collections.
AgreementWe evaluate everything and put together a consignment agreement.
Listed and marketedYour cards are professionally photographed, listed, and marketed to our collector base.
You get paidWhen an item sells, you're paid — minus our commission.
Monthly reportsYou'll receive detailed monthly reports on how your consignment is performing.
Consignment terms run up to 90 days. Anything unsold at that point can be returned to you, or we're happy to make a purchase offer on it directly.
Why choose Betz Legacy?
Fair market evaluations, backed by real, current sales data
Honest, transparent pricing — we'll explain how we arrived at any number
Secure transactions and careful handling of every item
Fast, responsive communication
26+ years being in business — not an anonymous online buyer
Experienced collectors who know the hobby and respect what your collection means to you
Get started
Contact us today with photos and details of your cards or collection, and we'll review your submission and walk you through the next steps — no pressure, no obligation.